To call an album a group’s third best would usually be faint praise, but not where the Band are concerned: 1970’s Stage Fright arguably ranks slightly behind its two predecessors in their catalog, but that’s only because those earlier records are their classic Music from Big Pink debut and their even better eponymous sophomore LP. In this group’s discography, third-best is still good enough to put an album on par with the finest releases of its era. It’s worth noting, moreover, that Stage Fright actually did better on the charts than either of the two earlier records.
Like those previous LPs, the self-produced Stage Fright sounds rooted in a mythic version of rural southern America (though all but one of the Band’s members were Canadian): if they’d had rock music in the South in the 1800s, it might have sounded a lot like this. There are zero specific references to life in 1970 in the frequently witty lyrics, though some of them could be interpreted as an oblique commentary on that time; dozens of lines on this album, meanwhile, harken back to an earlier era.
There are mentions of a faith healer, a medicine show, ragtime, a whistle-stop, a steamboat, a locomotive, and a trolley, as well as talk of sitting down by the fire and talking to “people all across the sea.” And the instrumentation can occasionally seem as anachronistic as the lyrics: hearing the accordion at the beginning of “Daniel & the Sacred Harp,” for example, it’s easy to imagine that you’re listening to people making music on a front porch a couple of centuries ago.
But the performances—which are more rock-oriented than those on Music from Big Pink and The Band—are timeless; these songs, which probably would have found an audience in 1870, sounded great a century later, and still sound great a half-century after that. While the lyrics often suggest sadness, disenchantment, and unease, the richly textured music is largely bright, upbeat, and catchy. Robbie Robertson (guitar, piano), Rick Danko (bass, fiddle), Levon Helm (drums, mandolin), Richard Manuel (keyboards, drums), and Garth Hudson (keyboards, horn) are all in fine form. Plus, the LP features terrific vocal work, particularly by Danko and Manuel.
The original record contains 10 songs, all but one of them (Manuel’s fine “Just Another Whistle Stop”) written (or in two cases co-written) by Robertson. The best-known numbers are the title cut, about grappling with fortune and fame, and “The Shape I’m In,” in which lead vocalist Manuel—whose sense of desperation reportedly inspired the lyric—memorably proclaims, “I just spent 60 days in the jailhouse / For the crime of having no dough / Now here I am back out on the street / For the crime of having nowhere to go.” Those are far from the album’s only high points, though; the other numbers—including “The W.S. Walcott Medicine Show,” “Daniel & the Sacred Harp,” “The Rumor,” “Time to Kill,” “All La Glory,” “Strawberry Wine,” and “Sleeping”—have left indelible marks as well.
Now, like its two predecessors, Stage Fright has been given the 50th-anniversary box-set treatment. A “super deluxe” edition features a fine-sounding remixed, remastered copy of the original record that restores the Band’s previously unreleased originally intended song sequencing and that has been augmented with nine bonus tracks: alternate mixes of “Strawberry Wine” and “Sleeping,” plus seven numbers that the group informally recorded with minimal instrumentation in a Calgary, Canada, hotel room in 1970. These include three Robertson compositions—“Get Up Jake” (two takes), “The W.S. Walcott Medicine Show,” and a number called “Calgary Blues”—plus Huey “Piano” Smith’s “Rockin’ Pneumonia and the Boogie Woogie Flu,” Bo Diddley’s “Before You Accuse Me,” and “Mojo Hannah,” a Motown number that Marvin Gaye once recorded.
That’s just for starters. A second CD features an excellent 20-song, 80-minute 1971 concert from London’s Royal Albert Hall that incorporates half the songs from Stage Fright plus such earlier classics as The Band’s “Across the Great Divide,” “The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down,” and “Rag Mama Rag,” and Music from Big Pink’s “The Weight” and Bob Dylan’s “I Shall Be Released.” A Blu-ray audio disc adds a spectacular DTS-HD surround-sound mix of the original album, the bonus tracks, and the London show. Also included are an audiophile-quality vinyl copy of Stage Fright, a seven-inch vinyl single, frameable lithographs, and a booklet that includes new liner notes by Robertson, period photos, an essay by photographer Norman Seeff on how his shoot for this album changed his life, and a 1970 LP review by the Los Angeles Times’ Robert Hilburn.
Unfortunately, these goodies do not come cheap: the handsomely packaged set is selling for around $150 (though the price seems likely to drop over time—that’s what happened with the Band’s two earlier anniversary boxes). The figure seems particularly steep considering that you can buy an edition that includes everything on both CDs—the upgraded album with the nine bonus tracks and the Royal Albert Hall concert—for less than 20 bucks. That said, some listeners might really want the vinyl; and there’s no question that this box’s Blu-ray adds a whole new—and thoroughly enjoyable—dimension to Stage Fright.
Sara Petite, Rare Bird. A press release accompanying this sixth album from singer/songwriter/guitarist Sara Petite emphasizes her rebel streak and penchant for blurring boundaries and mixing “forward-thinking country, bluegrass, amplified folk, and Springsteen-sized rock & roll.” Portions of Rare Bird do reflect that description, though some of its best material is solidly rooted in the contemporary country genre.
On hard rockers like “The Misfits,” whose lyrics seem to represent Petite’s declaration of independence from Nashville’s mainstream, her distinctive vocals get a bit lost in the mix; but give her a well-hooked, fiddle-spiced mid-tempo number where her voice is front and center and she’s darn near irresistible. She shines on songs like “Feeling Like an Angel,” “Missing You Tonight,” and “Floating with the Angels.” Also excellent are the retro “Crash, Boom Bang” and “I Just Keep Moving On,” a tribute to the late civil rights icon John Lewis that benefits from uncredited horn work.
Domenic Cicala, Come On Over: The Honky Tonk Duets. Washington, D.C.–based Domenic Cicala is a songwriter as well as a singer but on this understated latest album, his first since 2017, he focuses on cover material, including such classics as Tom Jans’s “Loving Arms”; “We Had It All,” by Donnie Fritts and Troy Seals; and Townes Van Zandt’s “If I Needed You.”
In addition to the top-notch material, the country-flavored album benefits from Cicala’s vocal duets with talented but not particularly well-known singers such as Michelle Hannan, BettySoo, and Mindy Miller. Add the acoustic instrumentation, which features a generous dose of steel guitar, and you have a lilting collection that’s likable from start to finish and at times even lovable.
The Red Step, The Red Step. Mix early Procol Harum with punk, garage rock, and metal, and you might have something close to the Red Step, a band of Serbian musicians that also features Londoner Sarah Jane Seatherton on cello.
On this eponymous debut from the group, which has been together for about six years, the sometimes difficult-to-make-out lyrics are subservient to the predominant keyboards, guitar, bass, and drums. But the group’s vitality and intensity come through loud and clear. The songs—all by vocalist/guitarist Tobias Nathaniel (though one track lists a cowriter)—take off in high gear, barrel forward with insistent beats, then slow abruptly before coming to a halt. This is probably not the kind of music that will find a wide audience, but some listeners are bound to savor it.
Jeff Burger’s website, byjeffburger.com, contains more than four decades’ worth of music reviews and commentary. His books include Dylan on Dylan: Interviews and Encounters, Lennon on Lennon: Conversations with John Lennon, Leonard Cohen on Leonard Cohen: Interviews and Encounters, and Springsteen on Springsteen: Interviews, Speeches, and Encounters.
2 thoughts on “Music Reviews: The Band’s ‘Stage Fright’ Expanded, Plus Sara Petite, Domenic Cicala, and the Red Step”